Replication Study Manuscript Evaluation Form

Title:
Reviewer:
Email Address:
Manuscript #:

 
N/A
1
2
3
4
5
Motivation for replication cleary stated and convincing
Study is consistent with replicated research
Adequately compares current results to prior results
Extends the previous study
Analysis of extension is appropriate for research question
Conclusions are appropriate given the results
Paper would be of interest to readership
Manuscript is well written

Recommendation:

Accept without revision
Accept subject to revisions, as noted in comments
Reject in current form, but may be resubmitted
Reject, with no resubmission

Authors will not receive a copy of this form. Please provide written comments to the authors as an email attachment (gpae@bryant.edu) in Word, WordPerfect, or ASCII. Include the manuscript title and number on the review comments and the manuscript number on the email's subject line. Do not indicate your recommendation in the author's review comments.

Please print this form for your record, and then click on the submit button below.